I voted Too Human. It is just as good as the others on the list when weighing up the pros and cons. I found 2008 to be another year of Nice Graphics ´n Silly Content. While I played a lot of new games this year, and have to admit some of them are well made, I still find the games of post 2000 to be more and more "casualized".
For each title released I find games moving further away from my dreams of "Games as Art".
I miss Interplay..... and Troika....